Skip to content

Subscription trap: an invoice for a plan you never ordered

A reminder or a charge for a subscription you do not remember taking out. If the order page lacks the right button, there is no contract. What to send in writing and how to get debited money back.

  • By Dennis Bölling
  • Updated 18 November 2026
  • 7 min read
  • 10 sources
Mock current account statement on a light background with a highlighted 39.90 euro direct debit for a subscription, with a “Never ordered” tag.
Contents

Usually it arrives in the post: an invoice, a payment reminder or a threat of debt collection for a contract you do not remember. Sometimes the subscription only shows up as a third-party line on your phone bill. The Hamburg consumer advice centre advises against paying such invoices and recommends objecting in writing. Whether a contract was made at all depends on how the order page was built.

What the reminder threatens

The letters threaten debt collection, some an entry with the credit bureau Schufa, and if a child is supposed to have ordered, a criminal complaint over false age details. The Hamburg consumer advice centre says none of this should intimidate you. A disputed claim may not be recorded, according to the centre, and once you have stated that no contract exists, you have nothing more to fear from the credit bureau. A payment you made at some earlier point does not confirm a contract either.

Example: payment reminder for a subscription never orderedRecreated example

Recreated. Sender, service and amounts are invented. The Hamburg consumer advice centre mentions threats involving the credit bureau Schufa.

Source: Hamburg consumer advice centre: subscription trap on the internet

When a contract exists and when it does not

Anyone selling something for a fee online must, under section 312j(3) BGB, design the ordering process so that you expressly confirm an obligation to pay. If you order through a button, it must be clearly legible and labelled with nothing other than the words “zahlungspflichtig bestellen” (order with obligation to pay) or a corresponding unambiguous wording. Under paragraph 4 the contract comes into being only if the provider meets this duty. No correctly labelled button therefore means no contract, and the Hamburg consumer advice centre reads it the same way.

Paragraphs 2 to 4 do not apply to contracts concluded exclusively through individual communication, such as email (section 312j(5)), and the duties under paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply to financial services. So whether you are bound depends on how the order was placed. Take a screenshot of the order page early, while you can still find it; the Hamburg centre expressly recommends it.

Before the order, the term, the cancellation conditions and the total costs must be stated clearly; if they are missing, the Hamburg consumer advice centre names a claim for damages. If you were not, or not fully, told about your right of withdrawal, you can still withdraw after two weeks have passed. According to the centre, contracts of minors without their parents’ consent are invalid, and parents are not liable for their children.

What to do now

  1. Do not pay.

    Not even when the reminder sounds harsh, the Hamburg consumer advice centre says. Leave any further invoices unpaid as well.

  2. Secure evidence.

    Save the invoice, the emails and the bank statement. Take a screenshot of the website if you can still find it.

  3. Object in writing.

    By registered letter, delivered by hand, you state that no contract was made. The Hamburg centre offers a free template letter for this.

  4. Stop ongoing debits.

    Return the direct debit through your bank and revoke the mandate. How long you have depends on whether there was a mandate.

  5. Consider withdrawing.

    If a contract was made, the withdrawal period under section 355 BGB is 14 days from the conclusion of the contract. Withdrawal needs no reason, and sending it in time is enough to keep the deadline. The period does not start before the provider has properly informed you. The right lapses at the latest twelve months and 14 days after the period begins (section 356 BGB).

If the invoice came by email, enter it at Check an email. For an account you are asked to pay, Check an IBAN shows whether reports exist. An unremarkable result is no assurance that the claim is justified. If you receive mail from a court, take it to a consumer advice centre, which can also assess your individual case.

If you have paid and think deception was involved, report it to the police. The routes by state are under Where to report it, the steps after a payment under Already paid?.

If the money has already been taken

The route back depends on how the money was taken. Nobody can promise the outcome.

Where was it debited?

Orientation, not legal advice. Deadlines under sections 675x and 676b BGB and according to the consumer advice centres.

Sources: Section 675x BGB; Section 676b BGB; Consumer advice centres: third-party billing block

What the law says about direct debits

For SEPA core direct debits you can, under section 675x(2) BGB, demand a refund from your bank without giving reasons. Under paragraph 4 the claim must be made within eight weeks of the debit. For debits without a mandate the consumer advice centres name up to 13 months. Section 676b BGB requires you to tell the bank without delay once you notice; if you report it more than 13 months after the debit, claims are excluded. This section is not legal advice.

Charges on the mobile phone bill

Identify the subscription operator from the details on the bill, deactivate the subscription and dispute the bill with the operator and your mobile provider at the same time. The consumer advice centres advise objecting to both, because the question of responsibility has not yet been settled by the highest court. Keep paying undisputed items so your line is not blocked. You request a third-party billing block from your mobile provider, by letter, by email or often in the customer portal. It applies only to billing through the phone bill and leaves mobile payment untouched.

Cancelling a genuine subscription

Since July 2022, providers with whom you can conclude a continuing contract on a website must offer cancellation there too (section 312k BGB). The button must be labelled “Verträge hier kündigen” (cancel contracts here) or an unambiguous equivalent and must always be available. It leads to a confirmation page where you send the cancellation with “jetzt kündigen” (cancel now) or an unambiguous equivalent. The provider must then confirm without delay, electronically, what you declared, when it arrived and when the contract ends. If you give no date, the earliest possible one applies in case of doubt. The rule does not apply to financial services.

If the buttons or the confirmation page are missing, section 312k(6) BGB lets you cancel the contract at any time without a notice period. According to the consumer advice centres’ page (as of 7 August 2026), the Federal Court of Justice ruled, on a claim by the Federation of German Consumer Organisations, that the confirmation page may show only the details needed for the cancellation. If the provider advertises extras there, the cancellation is treated as not correctly implemented.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to pay an invoice for a subscription I never took out?

The Hamburg consumer advice centre says no. State by registered letter, delivered by hand, that no contract was made, and keep the invoice and the emails.

What is the button rule?

Under section 312j BGB an online order must be designed so that you expressly confirm the obligation to pay, for example with a button labelled “zahlungspflichtig bestellen” (order with obligation to pay). Without that, no contract comes into being. The rule does not apply to contracts made exclusively through individual communication.

How long can I reverse a direct debit?

Eight weeks after the debit, without giving a reason (section 675x BGB). If money was taken without a mandate, the consumer advice centres name up to 13 months. Inform the bank without delay.

How do I cancel a subscription online?

Through the button “Verträge hier kündigen” or an unambiguous equivalent, then through “jetzt kündigen”. If the button is missing, you can cancel at any time without a notice period under section 312k(6) BGB.

Does something look off?

Check the message, the number or the IBAN before you react. Each warning sign comes with its reason.

Check an IBAN

Sources

  1. Section 312j German Civil Code: special duties in electronic commerce (button rule) (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  2. Section 312k German Civil Code: cancellation button for consumer contracts (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  3. Section 355 German Civil Code: right of withdrawal in consumer contracts (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  4. Section 356 German Civil Code: start and lapse of the withdrawal period (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  5. Section 675x German Civil Code: refund claim for SEPA direct debits (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  6. Section 676b German Civil Code: reporting unauthorised payments, 13-month limit (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  7. Hamburg consumer advice centre: Subscription trap on the internet, do not pay (as of 20 Feb 2026) (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  8. Consumer advice centres: cancellation button (as of 7 Aug 2026) (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  9. Consumer advice centres: paying by SEPA direct debit (as of 21 Sep 2026) (retrieved 17 November 2026)
  10. Consumer advice centres: third-party billing block, protection from unwanted subscriptions (as of 19 Aug 2026) (retrieved 17 November 2026)

Dennis Bölling, Founder, QAD Soft

The guides serve to inform and are researched with AI support. Individual cases may differ. For a legal assessment, contact your consumer advice centre or a qualified lawyer.